Jamie
Carragher admits he would be tougher with his criticism if another manager
was responsible for Chelsea's dip, but refused to add to the mounting
pressure on Frank Lampard, instead highlighting a potential lack of
experience at the top level.
Chelsea's fifth Premier League defeat of the season was confirmed inside 45
minutes of Sunday's clash with Manchester City as a three-goal lead at the
break laid the foundation for a comprehensive 3-1 away victory at Stamford
Bridge.
A run of just one victory in six league outings has left Chelsea seven
points off leaders Liverpool having played a game more, and seen Lampard's
position come under intense scrutiny after registering the lowest
points-per-game average of any manager of the Roman Abramovich era.
Jamie Carragher labelled Chelsea "mentally fragile" following the manner of
their defeat to City, and the Sky Sports pundits insisted Lampard should be
compared to those who came before him.
Is it fair comparing Frank to predecessors?
"Of course it is fair, he's the Chelsea manager," Carragher told Monday
Night Football. "Nobody knows Chelsea Football Club, and how ruthless they
are with managers, more than Frank Lampard.
"Having played with Frank, we get questioned whether we would be more
critical of the situation if it was a different manager. They would be
right, I would be a lot more critical of the managers on that list. Not
because I played with Frank Lampard but because I don't expect him to win
the Premier League or the Champions League [this season].
"The other managers that came in with CVs, years of experience, having won
the big trophies - Jose Mourinho, Guus Hiddink, Carlo Ancelotti, all great
managers - I would be more critical of them."
Is
Lampard part of a generation lacking experience?
With Lampard among a new generation of managers to have secured a
high-profile position early in their careers, Carragher questioned whether
managers were landing the top jobs before they had earned enough experience
to cope with the position.
"I think of players of my generation, I think of myself… I watch Jurgen
Klopp on the sideline, fist-pumping The Kop when Liverpool have won, and I
want to be him, it looks amazing," he added.
"Frank Lampard wants to be Jose Mourinho, John Terry wants to be Jose
Mourinho, I'm sure Thierry Henry looks at Arsene Wenger and thinks, 'I'd
love to do that, I could do that'.
"What I'd say about players of my generation, and why I do punditry, is that
I want to be Jurgen Klopp managing Liverpool, but I don't want to go to
Mainz for seven years and work my way up. That's what I'm talking about with
Frank. I actually admire the job he did last year, and [after the Manchester
City defeat] I admired his interview.
"Frank went into a top job on the back of 12 months at Derby, the experience
isn't there. He didn't get the job on the back of being a great manager, he
got it because of Chelsea and Frank Lampard.
"Gary Neville went to Valencia, big job, how could he say no? Thierry Henry
went to Monaco. How could Frank say no to Chelsea? But they don't have that
experience to fall back on, they haven't learned the ups and downs of
management and coaching.
"Steven Gerrard has gone to Rangers and is doing really well and it looks
like they might win the title this season. But would I want Steven Gerrard
to be Liverpool manager without more experience? Possibly not.
"I just think when you get those really big jobs and you haven't got that
experience, you've got nothing to fall back on when times are tough, as they
will be now over the next few weeks for Frank.
"Even the confidence and belief in how you think your team should play [will
be questioned]. People have ideas when they go into coaching or managing how
their team should play, but they don't know until they've done it and got
confidence that it works.
"That's why I won't go to town on Frank Lampard right now. It's not that he
doesn't know football, it's just that they haven't got the experience to
fall back on.
"I'd love Frank Lampard at Chelsea, Steven Gerrard at Liverpool, Thierry
Henry in those jobs in 10 years' time so they can actually show, with that
experience they have built up, they have that confidence and are ready."
Ince: I couldn't say no, but it was too
early
Monday Night Football guest Paul Ince reflected on his transition into
management that saw him start out with spells at Macclesfield Town and MK
Dons before being earning his first Premier League appointment when
Blackburn Rovers came calling in 2008.
It was Ince's third managerial appointment, but he would only last six
months at Ewood Park before being relieved of his duties. He admits the
position was one he could not turn down, despite it coming too soon in his
career.
"I was thinking about management when I was 31, that was always going to be
my next step. I knew there was going to be a process of how I would do it,
and I ended up going into League Two and bottom club Macclesfield," he said.
"It was not a job I would have probably envisaged seeing myself having after
the career I had. That's why Frank Lampard and Steven Gerrard are lucky
people, getting propelled into these bigger clubs.
"But I was happy to do that, learn from the bottom and work my way up. If I
was offered one of those jobs, I couldn't have said no.
"I got the Blackburn job, lasted six months, we weren't in the bottom three.
It was still too soon for me to take the job, but I couldn't turn it down.
My rise in management was so quick from League Two, League One and then
straight to the Premier League that it was too early for me.
"The game had changed, the players had changed and weren't the same as in my
generation, but I couldn't turn the job down."
Ince: Frank needs someone to lean on
Ince has questioned whether Lampard has the older heads with experience in
his coaching set-up to confide in when the going gets tough.
"Steven Gerrard has done well as he's taken Gary McAllister with him, but
when things go wrong for Frank, who does he talk to?" he added.
"We know Jody Morris is a very good coach, but who is that senior person he
can turn to and ask what to do in certain situations? I wouldn't know what
Frank would have said at half-time against Manchester City. What do you say?
"There is no getting away from it, if you spend that kind of money on
players - whether you're Lampard or Ancelotti - you're going to be under
pressure. But that is where you need someone who has played and managed
among the higher echelons to lean on."
top