
We
round up the controversial calls involving Premier League champions Chelsea
from Ref Watch over the past 12 months.
Former top flight referee Dermot Gallagher has been running the rule over
the key decisions in the Premier League on Sky Sports News HQ every Monday,
but how many have gone for and against the Blues?
Here, we take a look at the most contentious and most important calls of the
2016/17 season. Tomorrow, we continue with Liverpool...
Watford 1-2 Chelsea, August 20
INCIDENT: Diego Costa avoids a second yellow for 'simulation'. Having
already been booked, Costa goes over on the edge of the box following the
slightest of challenges from Watford defender Miguel Britos. However, the
referee decides the Chelsea striker did not dive. Costa then goes on to
score the winning goal.
DERMOT'S VERDICT: Correct decision - The law says 'deceiving the referee
into give a free kick or penalty'. The referee has to decide whether he's
made a deliberate simulation to win a free kick or penalty. In the case
where a player is on a yellow card he must be 100 per cent sure to send him
off. If he has any doubt whatsoever he's got to back off and that's what I
think happened here. The referee wasn't sure whether Costa actually
initiated contact or the contact was initiated on him and he chose not give
a red card. I think that's absolutely right because looking at that I think
it is simulation, but if I was going to send him off I would want to be
absolutely sure.
Swansea City 2-2 Chelsea, September 11
INCIDENT: Gary Cahill is tackled from behind by Leroy Fer, who then goes
through to score. Chelsea's central defender loses the ball to the Dutchman
in the build-up to Swansea's second goal, with referee Andre Marriner
allowing play to continue.
DERMOT'S VERDICT: Incorrect decision - The referee has gone to what is a
natural position, expecting the ball to be cleared up field. It is played
across the park, Cahill has dwelt on the ball and he thinks Leroy Fer has
poked the ball between his legs from where he is. But he has not and he
[Marriner] has completely misread it, so it is a foul.
Chelsea 4-0 Manchester United, October 23
INCIDENT: David Luiz is booked for a tackle on Marouane Fellaini. With
Chelsea winning 2-0, Luiz is only shown yellow even though the challenge was
with his studs, catching Fellaini on his knee.
DERMOT'S VERDICT: Incorrect decision - If the referee sees the angle we have
seen, he would definitely show a red card because he has shown six studs,
caught him high on the knee and the ball has gone. Martin Atkinson is the
other side and has seen the high boot. He thought he caught him, but didn't
see the seriousness. I thought it was a red card. If you go in that high
with studs showing, you run that risk.
Manchester City 1-3 Chelsea, December 3
INCIDENT: With the score goalless, Chelsea defender David Luiz appears to
block Sergio Aguero as the Manchester City striker attempts to break through
on goal. Referee Anthony Taylor puts his whistle to his lips, but instead
decides against awarding a free-kick despite the apparent foul that denied a
goalscoring opportunity and would have seen Luiz sent off.
DERMOT'S VERDICT: Incorrect decision - David Luiz knows what he's doing, the
ball is within possession of Aguero once he gets past. The ball then only
runs away because he stops him. I think it's a foul and a red card.
You see Anthony make that decision in his head, then he takes his whistle
away. All I can think is he's had some input from one of his assistants to
say it's not [a foul] from their angle. That does surprise me because,
having seen the incident, if I was the referee you'd have to sell me a big,
big deal for me to change my mind like that.
Manchester City 1-3 Chelsea, December 3
INCIDENT: Diego Costa scores the equalising goal for Chelsea despite
appearing to use his arm in the build-up. The Chelsea striker isn't
penalised, beats Nicolas Otamendi and goes on to find the back of the net.
The goal is allowed to stand and the Blues go on to win the game.
DERMOT'S VERDICT: Correct decision - I think he's taking it on his chest.
His arm is out, but for balance. Otamendi appeals at the end but his first
priority is to go after the ball. He doesn't even stop to think he's handled
the ball, and for me he's taken it well and it was a good goal.
Chelsea 2-0 Hull, January 22
INCIDENT: With the score at 1-0 to Chelsea in the second half, Marcos Alonso
kicks the back of Abel Hernandez's heel in the penalty area after miscuing a
clearance. No penalty is given by the officials, despite the incident
occurring in front of the linesman.
DERMOT'S VERDICT: Alonso is lucky. Very, very lucky. And I think he knows it
too, his reaction tells it. It just wasn't a wise decision to make. He has
trod on his heel, and again it's one that I thought the assistant could have
seen, rather than the referee.
Liverpool 1-1 Chelsea, January 31
INCIDENT: Jurgen Klopp escaped punishment for shouting in Neil Swarbrick's
face following Mark Clattenburg's decision to award Chelsea a penalty after
Joel Matip's second-half challenge on Diego Costa. Klopp afterwards revealed
that Swarbrick congratulated him on his 'passion' once he had received an
apology from the Reds manager.
Manchester United boss Jose Mourinho took aim at Klopp and accused Premier
League referees of favouring the German after he was told to sit down for a
similar outburst during Manchester United's goalless draw with Hull the
following day.
DERMOT'S VERDICT: Incorrect decision - The fourth official who spoke to Jose
Mourinho acted within the guidelines and the procedures he was given at the
start of the season.
The problem emanates from the fact that, when you watch Jurgen Klopp on
Tuesday night, for me in view of the procedures, that's totally
unacceptable. It was something that had to be dealt with and it wasn't dealt
with. I feel that Klopp should have been removed without doubt.
Chelsea 3-1 Arsenal, February 4
INCIDENT: Marcos Alonso and Arsenal defender Hector Bellerin both jumped to
attack the ball in the six-yard box with the Chelsea man winning the battle
and heading home for 1-0. However, as he jumped, he caught Bellerin with his
arm, knocking the full-back to the ground. Arsene Wenger called it a "100
per cent foul." The goal stood.
DERMOT'S VERDICT: Correct decision - They've both jumped with their arms in
the air and both are focused on the ball. Alonso never looks at Bellerin
once. It was natural contact. It would have been more of a surprise if it
had been disallowed.
Manchester United 2-0 Chelsea, April 16
INCIDENT: Ander Herrera appears to handle Nemanja Matic's pass. The United
midfielder blocks the Serb's through ball with his hand, but referee Bobby
Madley deems it accidental, with the home side then going on to open the
scoring.
DERMOT'S VERDICT: Incorrect decision - I thought it was (handball), but what
I would say in defence of the referee, if you watch he has a great view, he
makes a decision and clearly says: 'No'. So although I think he has got it
wrong, I will applaud the referee for not hiding behind the fact like there
was a player in my way, I was at the wrong angle. All I can presume is that
he has judged a) the ball has come too close to him and his arm was already
there and b) it has hit him too fast.
The amazing thing about it is as a consequence the ball quickly goes to
Marcus Rashford and he scores, so it is a massive, massive incident and that
is how fine a line referees tread. If that ball had just gone out for a
throw in, we would not be talking about it.