Ashley
Barnes should have been sent off for his foul on Chelsea midfielder Nemanja
Matic, believes former Premier League referee Dermot Gallagher.
Speaking to Sky Sports News HQ, Gallagher gave his opinion on the
controversial incidents from an exciting weekend of Premier League action -
including a number of decisions froM Chelsea's 1-1 draw with Burnley.
Ashley Barnes on Branislav Ivanovic
WHAT HAPPENED: Burnley striker Barnes appeared to catch Chelsea
defender Ivanovic in an aerial challenge. Ivanovic rolled over twice before
getting up in anger after realising that the referee was taking no action
against him.
DERMOT'S VIEW: "I thought it warranted a yellow card. It
was a reckless challenge. I didn’t think it was dangerous or seriously
endangering the safety of an opponent. Therefore a yellow card was
sufficient on this occasion."
Michael Kightly handball
WHAT HAPPENED: Ivanovic shoots from the edge of the area, but the
ball hits Kightly’s outstretched arm after he turned his back to the Chelsea
defender.
DERMOT'S VIEW: "I'm on the side of the referee here.
Handball has got to be deliberate. Handball has become such an emotive
subject, but I think on this occasion the balls hit at speed and it’s
travelled a very short distance, Kightly’s turned away, for me I would say
that there’s enough doubt not to give a penalty."
Diego Costa penalty appeal
WHAT HAPPENED: Costa tumbles to the ground after Burnley captain
Jason Shackell brings him down clumsily from behind. Again the referee
Martin Atkinson turns down the appeals.
DERMOT'S VIEW: "For me it’s a penalty. If you make a
challenge like that and you knock the player over you’ve got to get the
ball, and without doubt he didn’t get the ball. He’s taken a risk, and he’s
gotten away with it."
Barnes foul on Nemanja Matic:
WHAT HAPPENED: Burnley striker Barnes appeared to catch Matic just
below the knee with a challenge during Saturday’s 1-1 draw at Stamford
Bridge. The Chelsea midfielder was then sent off for his reaction as he
pushed his opponent to the floor.
DERMOT'S VIEW: "On the replay, quite clearly, it was a red
card. I think the referee saw it but I don’t think he recognised the
severity of it. I was watching the game live and the commentator didn’t even
recognise the severity of it. If you look at the reaction of the players,
it’s only Matic that realises the seriousness of the tackle. He reacts, but
the other players don’t. When you look at it without doubt it’s a very bad
tackle, it’s a red card."
Matic’s reaction that saw him sent off:
DERMOT'S VIEW: "Everybody in the country will be saying how
unfortunate he (Matic) is. But everybody knows you can’t react like that.
He’s reacted badly and he’s reacted violently towards his opponent, so the
referee has sent him off. It is a red card for violent conduct."
Southampton penalty appeal: Emre Can on Filip Djuricic
WHAT HAPPENED: Djuricic, making his first start for Southampton,
burst through on goal after just 30 seconds, only for Liverpool defender
Emre Can to bundle the forward to the ground.
DERMOT'S VIEW: "No, there was not enough contact to put him
down, for me it’s a coming together
Southampton penalty appeal: Joe Allen on Djuricic
WHAT HAPPENED: The Southampton midfielder went through a few
minutes later, this time being brought down by Liverpool midfielder Joe
Allen. But once again the Saints’ penalty appeals were waved away. The Reds
went on to win 2-0.
DERMOT'S VIEW: "Yes, I think that was a penalty. On that
occasion he (Allen) gets the man and not the ball. It was not a coming
together and it’s a penalty."
Liverpool penalty appeal: Jose Fonte on Raheem Sterling
WHAT HAPPENED: Liverpool forward Raheem Sterling appeared to be
tripped in the box by Southampton captain Jose Fonte, but penalty appeals
were turned down by referee Kevin Friend.
Jose Fonte tackles Raheem Sterling
DERMOT'S VIEW: "100% no, he (Fonte) definitely gets the
ball. He slides in and his momentum takes him through because of the
conditions. But, without doubt, he gets the ball first."
top